The Roth 5-year rules are two separate clocks. One decides when your Roth IRA earnings come out tax-free. The other runs for each Roth conversion and decides whether you owe a 10% additional tax on converted money you take out before 59½.
After 59½, only the first clock still matters. If your first Roth IRA is at least five tax years old, everything you withdraw comes out tax-free.
If you’ve read two explanations of the 5-year rule that seemed to disagree, they were likely describing different clocks. Here’s how each one starts, what it controls, and how to plan withdrawals around both.
What Are the Two Roth 5-Year Rules?
The first rule covers earnings. The second covers converted money. They start at different times, and only the earnings rule still applies after 59½.
| Earnings rule | Conversion rule | |
|---|---|---|
| What starts the clock | Your first contribution or conversion to any Roth IRA | Every conversion, one clock each |
| When the clock starts | January 1 of the tax year your first contribution or conversion counts toward | January 1 of the year you convert |
| What it controls | Whether earnings come out tax-free | Whether converted money owes the 10% additional tax |
| Still applies after 59½? | Yes | No |
| If you withdraw too soon | Earnings are taxed, plus 10% before 59½ unless an exception applies | 10% additional tax on the taxable converted amount |
Source: IRS Publication 590-B (2025).
How Does the Roth IRA 5-Year Rule for Earnings Work?
Roth IRA earnings come out tax-free only in a qualified distribution. That takes two things: five tax years since your first Roth IRA contribution or conversion, and a qualifying event.
The clock starts on January 1 of the tax year your first contribution or conversion counts toward. Make your first contribution in April 2027 for the 2026 tax year, and your clock started January 1, 2026. You’d clear it on January 1, 2031.
You get one clock for all your Roth IRAs. Opening a second Roth IRA later doesn’t restart it, and a first conversion starts it the same way a contribution does.
The qualifying events are:
- Reaching age 59½
- Becoming disabled
- Death, when your beneficiary or estate takes the money
- Buying a first home, up to $10,000 over your lifetime
Your regular contributions sit outside this rule. You can take them out at any time, tax-free, whatever your age.
How Does the 5-Year Rule Work for Roth Conversions?
Each Roth conversion gets its own five-year clock. If you’re under 59½, withdrawing converted money before its clock runs out triggers a 10% additional tax. It applies to the part that was taxable when you converted, and you don’t owe income tax on it a second time.
The clock starts January 1 of the year you convert, whatever the date. A conversion in December 2026 counts from January 1, 2026, so it clears on January 1, 2031. A late-year conversion gives up nothing on the clock.
Sarah Busch, CFP® professional and Head of Services at Boldin, makes the case for waiting. “When planning a Roth conversion, wait until the last two months of the year to decide how much to convert,” she says. “By then, you’ll have a clearer view of your total income, making it easier to manage your tax bracket and avoid surprises.”
Three conversions in three years mean three clocks. Withdrawals come out of the oldest conversion first, so the earliest clocks matter most. Pulling converted money out too soon is on our list of Roth mistakes that cost you in taxes.
Only the taxable part of a conversion is exposed to the 10% additional tax. A backdoor Roth converts after-tax money, so its conversion clock carries little or no risk, unless the pro-rata rule makes part of it taxable.
Does the 5-Year Rule Apply After 59½?
Only the earnings clock does. After 59½, the conversion clocks stop mattering, and converted money comes out with no 10% additional tax at any point.
Whether earnings are tax-free depends on how long you’ve had a Roth IRA. If your first Roth IRA contribution or conversion was at least five tax years ago, your withdrawals are qualified and tax-free.
Say you open your first Roth IRA at 62 by converting $100,000 in 2026, and the account grows to $110,000. Withdraw $105,000 in 2028, and the first $100,000 is converted money, with no tax and no 10%. The other $5,000 is earnings. You’ll owe income tax on it because your clock doesn’t clear until 2031, but no 10% additional tax, since you’re past 59½.
Leave the earnings in until 2031, and the whole account comes out tax-free.
In What Order Do Roth IRA Withdrawals Come Out?
The IRS treats every Roth IRA withdrawal as coming out in a set order, across all your Roth IRAs combined:
- Your regular contributions, which come out tax-free at any age
- Converted money, oldest conversion first, with the taxable part of each before the nontaxable part
- Earnings, last
The order works in your favor. If you’ve contributed $40,000 over the years, you can take out $40,000 before touching a converted dollar or a cent of earnings.
What Do You Owe If You Withdraw Early?
Your age and the age of your first Roth IRA decide the bill. Here’s how each kind of money is treated.
| Money withdrawn | Under 59½: income tax | Under 59½: 10% additional tax | 59½ or older: income tax | 59½ or older: 10% additional tax |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Contributions | No | No | No | No |
| Conversions, less than 5 years | No | Yes, on the taxable part | No | No |
| Conversions, 5 years or more | No | No | No | No |
| Earnings, first Roth IRA under 5 years old | Yes | Yes | Yes | No |
| Earnings, first Roth IRA 5 years or older | Yes | Yes | No | No |
Source: IRS Publication 590-B (2025). Exceptions such as disability or a first home can change the under-59½ columns.
Before 59½, several exceptions waive the 10% additional tax, including disability and some medical bills. Income tax on earnings still applies unless the withdrawal is qualified.
How Do the 5-Year Rules Work for a Roth 401(k)?
A Roth 401(k) has its own five-year clock, and each plan keeps a separate one. It starts January 1 of the first year you made Roth contributions to that plan. Qualified withdrawals also need age 59½, disability, or death.
Rolling a Roth 401(k) into a Roth IRA is where the clocks catch people. The years in the plan don’t count toward the Roth IRA clock. If you already have a Roth IRA, its older start date applies. If the rollover opens your first Roth IRA, the clock starts that year.
That’s a reason to open a Roth IRA, even with a small contribution, years before you roll over a workplace plan. Roth 401(k)s haven’t had required minimum distributions since 2024, so there’s less pressure to move the money early.
How Can Early Retirees Use the Conversion Clock?
The conversion clock is what makes a Roth conversion ladder work. You convert part of a traditional IRA or 401(k) each year. Five years later, that amount comes out with no 10% additional tax, even before 59½.
Say you retire at 50 with savings in a taxable account and a traditional IRA. You convert $40,000 a year starting in 2027, while your income is low. The 2027 conversion clears on January 1, 2032. The taxable account covers 2027 through 2031, and from 2032 on, another $40,000 clears each year.
The catch is the five-year gap. You need other money to live on while the first conversions wait. That’s why a ladder often runs alongside other ways to withdraw before 59½.
How Do You Keep Track of Your Roth Clocks?
Keep a simple record: the tax year of your first Roth IRA contribution or conversion, plus the year and amount of every conversion. Form 8606 reports your conversions and Roth IRA withdrawals, but it won’t tell you when a clock clears. Custodians report what goes in and out, and the clocks are yours to track.
The Boldin Planner models Roth conversions year by year, with the taxes each one triggers and the order you draw from each account. It doesn’t track the five-year clocks, so check your conversion dates before you schedule withdrawals.
For a second opinion on a conversion plan, Boldin Advisors’ CFP® professionals offer one-on-one advice. A free small-group discovery session explains how it works.
FAQs About the Roth 5-Year Rules
Does each Roth conversion have its own 5-year rule?
Each Roth conversion starts its own five-year clock on January 1 of the year you convert. If you’re under 59½, withdrawing converted money before its clock runs out costs a 10% additional tax on the taxable part. The IRS counts your oldest conversions as withdrawn first, and those clocks clear first.
Does the 5-year rule apply to a backdoor Roth?
A backdoor Roth faces the 5-year rule in a limited way. It converts after-tax money, and only the taxable part of a conversion is exposed to the 10% additional tax. The catch is the pro-rata rule: if you hold other pretax IRA money, part of the conversion becomes taxable. A first backdoor conversion also starts your earnings clock.
Can I withdraw Roth IRA contributions before 5 years?
Regular Roth IRA contributions come out at any time, at any age, with no income tax and no 10% additional tax. Withdrawals count as contributions first, so you can reach the full amount you’ve contributed before touching converted money or earnings. The 5-year rules affect what comes after.
Does rolling a Roth 401(k) into a Roth IRA restart the 5-year clock?
The years in your Roth 401(k) don’t carry over. If you already have a Roth IRA, its original start date applies to the rolled-over money. If the rollover creates your first Roth IRA, a new five-year clock starts on January 1 of that year. Opening a small Roth IRA early avoids the reset.
What are the exceptions to the Roth 5-year rule?
Roth IRA contributions are exempt from the 5-year rule. For earnings, the five tax years still apply. Turning 59½, disability, death, or a first-home purchase up to $10,000 supplies the other half of a qualified withdrawal. Before 59½, exceptions such as disability can waive the 10% additional tax, though not the income tax on earnings.
Do heirs have to wait out the Roth 5-year rule?
Heirs inherit the original owner’s clock. If the owner’s first Roth IRA contribution or conversion was at least five tax years before the withdrawal, the money comes out tax-free. If not, earnings are taxable until the five years pass, though heirs don’t owe the 10% additional tax. Contributions and converted money come out tax-free either way.